Categories
Real Estate InvestingPublished October 21, 2026
Pay Off Debt or Buy a Rental? Why Every Debt You Kill Is a Rental You Get for Free
For most people, paying off consumer debt first beats buying a rental. In my experience, a rental clears about $200 to $300 a month after the mortgage, so a single $499 car payment takes roughly two rentals to replace. Pay off the car and you get the same $499 back with no down payment, no tenants, and no repairs.
The math that made me put my coffee down
The other night I did the math on how many rentals I'd need to never work again.
The answer made me put my coffee down.
Dozens.
Not a handful. Dozens of properties, each with its own roof, its own furnace, and its own tenant who has my phone number.
I've sold real estate for years, and I own rentals myself. I'm not guessing at what a rental brings in. So when the answer came back that big, I knew the math wasn't the problem. The plan was.
What one rental really makes per month
Here's my honest number. After the mortgage is paid, each of my rentals brings in around $200 to $300 a month. That's on a good month.
That's my own experience, not a market average. But it's a lot less than most people picture when they say they want to "get into rentals."
And plenty of things line up to take a bite out of it:
- Empty months. When a tenant moves out, the mortgage still comes due.
- Repairs. Water heaters, furnaces, and roofs break when they want to, not when it's convenient.
- Turnover. Cleaning and paint between tenants come out of your pocket.
- The 2 a.m. call. Sooner or later, a toilet overflows in the middle of the night. Somebody has to deal with it, and it's usually you.
None of this makes rentals bad. It just means $200 to $300 is the best case, not a promise.
My $499 car payment vs. two rentals
Then I looked at my own car payment. It's $499 a month.
So I asked myself a simple question. What would it take to make $499 a month from rentals?
One rental doesn't get there. Two rentals bring in about $400 to $600 on a good month. So it takes roughly two properties to replace that one car payment.
Buy two rentals
- Two down payments
- Two inspections and two sets of closing costs
- Two sets of tenants to find and keep happy
- Two properties that can sit empty or break down
- About $400 to $600 a month, if everything goes right
Pay off one car loan
- No down payment
- No closing costs
- No tenants
- No toilets
- The same $499 a month back in your pocket
That's $5,988 a year that stays with you for as long as the loan would have run. It doesn't depend on a tenant, and it doesn't vanish when a pipe bursts.
Every debt you kill is a rental you get for free
That's when it clicked. Every debt you kill is a rental you get for free. And it never calls you at 2 a.m.
A rental is supposed to put money in your pocket every month. A paid-off payment does the same thing, except it never sits empty, never needs a new roof, and never misses rent.
It works with almost any monthly payment:
- Car loans. My own example. One payoff did the work of about two rentals.
- Credit cards. That monthly payment is money that could be working for you instead.
- Personal loans. Once it's gone, that money is yours again.
Good debt vs. bad debt: when a rental mortgage makes sense
I'm not against debt. I have mortgages on rentals. But here's how I see it. Rentals exist so their monthly income can pay your personal bills. That only works if your personal bills aren't already buried under car loans and credit cards. Otherwise, your payments eat the rent money before you ever see it, and all you've really added is a tenant.
So I only take on what people call "good debt," a mortgage on a rental, after the consumer debt is gone. Once it is, even a rental with a mortgage can start covering real bills.
A couple of people who commented on my original post pushed this idea further. One reader pointed out that real freedom shows up when you own your rentals with no mortgage at all, or when you can pay a property manager to take those late-night calls.
Another reader took the same mindset in a different order. They got completely debt-free first, with no house, car, or loan payments. Then they bought rentals to pay for the extras they wanted. There was a fun toy they couldn't justify a payment for, so they let a rental's income cover it. The rental pays for the want, so the paycheck doesn't have to.
What this looks like if you're buying rentals in Mansfield and Richland County
A starter rental in Mansfield is within reach for a lot of people who live here. That's a great thing. It's also exactly why it's so tempting to jump in before the car loan is gone.
Before you buy, run the numbers on that specific property. Rent, taxes, and insurance can change from one town to the next, and even from one street to the next. You can see the communities I work in on my areas we serve page.
Here's what I'd look at with you on any rental:
- Realistic rent. What a place like it actually rents for, not the highest number you can find.
- Taxes and insurance. They're part of the real monthly cost from day one.
- The big stuff. The age of the roof, furnace, and water heater tells you what's coming.
- Your own payments. If debt is eating your paycheck, the rent money won't go far.
If there's a property in Richland County you're eyeing, send it my way. I'll walk through the numbers with you and tell you straight if I think the debt should go first.
Kill the debt. Then buy the doors.
Everyone wants to buy their way to freedom. Most of us need to pay our way there first.
I own rentals, I believe in them, and I help people buy them. But a rental that has to fight your car payment for every dollar isn't freedom. It's one more thing on your plate.
So here's my rule. Kill the debt. Then buy the doors.
When you're ready, reach out. I'd be happy to run the numbers on a rental with you.
This is my experience as an agent and rental owner, not financial or tax advice.
Frequently asked questions
Should I pay off debt before buying a rental property?
For most people, yes. Paying off a consumer payment returns that money every month with no tenants, repairs, or empty months, while a rental's income can disappear with one bad month.
How much does a rental property make per month?
It varies by property. In my experience owning rentals, a typical one clears about $200 to $300 a month after the mortgage on a good month, before surprise repairs.
How many rentals does it take to replace a car payment?
At $200 to $300 per rental, a $499 car payment takes about two rentals to replace. Paying off the loan gets you the same monthly money without buying anything.
Is a rental mortgage good debt?
It can be, once your consumer debt is gone and the property's income covers its costs with room to spare. I only use rental debt after paying off consumer debt.
Can you buy rental property in Mansfield, Ohio with a mortgage?
Yes. Many local investors finance their rentals. The key is running each property's real rent, taxes, insurance, and repair costs before you buy, and making sure your own debts aren't eating the income.
Justin Bigelow
Realtor® | Justin Bigelow, Realtor | Dream Huge Realty
or another way
